Posted by: Jeremy C. Young | March 11, 2011

Why We Should Go to War in Libya

If you are a pacifist, I understand why you don’t want to go to war in Libya. If you believe wars should only be fought to defend the homeland, I understand why you don’t want to go to war in Libya. If you believe war is a legitimate instrument of public policy, however, I fail to understand what war could be more just, or more necessary, than the one we could be fighting in Libya right now.

Let’s enumerate the reasons:

– Muammar Gaddafi is a brutal and anti-democratic dictator. He has consistently brutalized his own people and deprived them of rights and elections; he is currently killing them by the thousands using tanks and aircraft. The humanitarian situation cries out for action.

– There is a viable democratic movement in Libya that has asked for our aid. This was not true in Iraq (not viable) or Afghanistan (not democratic). We would not need to carry the brunt of the war ourselves, nor should we.

– People are dying. We could help them. They have asked for our help.

– Freeing Arab people from the clutches of a brutal dictator — by helping an existing revolution and then getting out of the way — would give us enormous credibility in the Middle East. It would show young potential Jihadis that Americans care about their well-being.

Additionally, here are some reasons a war in Libya should be an easy choice politically for President Obama:

– Gaddafi is an anti-American. His Libya is a state sponsor of terror. He has personally sponsored terrorist attacks on U.S. citizens (the bombing of Pan Am 103 in Lockerbie); his palace portico sports a bronze statue of a fist smashing a U.S. fighter plane. I don’t care a bit whether he’s anti-American, but it should make the political calculus easier for Obama.

– An intervention in Libya would help U.S. oil markets. I don’t care a bit for U.S. oil markets, but it should make the political calculus easier for Obama.

– We could go to war under the aegis of the U.N., if we just pressed Russia a little harder. I confess I do care about the U.N., but more importantly it should make the political calculus easier for Obama.

I think this country has spent so long fighting immoral and ill-advised wars that we have forgotten what a noble and justified war looks like. Let me be clear: I am not suggesting that we should take the brunt of the fighting upon ourselves, or that we should play a major role in rebuilding the country. Instead, we should establish a no-fly zone, arm the rebels, and then get out of the way after they have reconquered their country. People are dying, and they need our help. Have we forgotten what it means to be an international good samaritan?

About these ads


  1. The Colonel had nothing to do with Lockerbie, which was a revege bombing carried out jointly by Iran and the US to giver the former country a one and one one revenge for the downing of IR655

  2. We are in general agreement except a formal ‘no-fly zone” is not required. Simply have the US Navy shoot down a couple of Libyan MiG’s and it is the last plane we will see in the sky except those fleeing the country. The pilots are not stupid, they know they have obsolete warplanes. Antiques in a few cases with the Mirages

    This is a supply and training mission for the SOF mostly, with some CIA help and help from friendly Arab states to lend some experienced NCO’s to help impart unit discipline. Nothing sophisticated, the rebels need basics, not pie in the sky

  3. Your facts are confused to say the least….we have NO business going into Libya. Using your set of irrational excuses there are at least 5 countries where we could go in before Libya. If you want to go to war, join military tough guy….I have been in a combat zone for a year…There is NO justification for this insanity. This is wag the dog for obama and because Libya has the largest oil reserves in Africa….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s



Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: